First, Jim Cooper did not have a conservative opponent. The candidate occupying the Republican line on the ballot was Scott Knapp, a mixed-bag who had few conservative credentials. Knapp lists the #1 issue in our district as “energy policy,” and on Iraq, Knapp’s viewpoint descends into the pessimism of a liberal.
He states “I do not think we should have gone to war in Iraq. Now that we’re there, we’ve got to do something. I’m not 100% sure what. I think it will deteriorate into chaos. Let it go back to what it used to be, three separate countries. Let the Kurds, Shiites and Sunnis have their section. Hopefully, we’ll get along with the Kurds, best-case scenario the Shiites won’t hate us, and the Sunnis are probably a lost cause.”
On the Bush tax cuts, Knapp also apparently reads from the DNC’s talking points, stating “If [Bush] wants to make them permanent, he needs to find where to cut the spending.” Knapp is correct in his argument that government spends too much, but he ignores the positive effect tax cuts have on the economy and revenue collections.
Therefore, as a conservative, one had to turn to Jim Cooper to see what he offered.
Mr. Cooper, who is a little more grounded in reality, lists the #1 issue in our district as “a tie between the war and jobs.” Although Cooper does not agree with the President on Iraq, he still has the sensible outlook that “It’s no good looking backward. We need to support our troops and try to get them home safely and as quickly as possible.”
The American Conservative Union has given Jim Cooper a 36 rating (out of 100) based on his voting record. That’s more liberal than conservative, but among Cooper’s fellow Tennessee Democrat congressmen, he’s more conservative than Bart Gordon and Harold Ford, Jr., and more liberal than Lincoln Davis and John Tanner.
Despite his rating, Jim Cooper has hit several home runs. He was one of only 36 House Democrats who voted for the Federal Marriage Amendment, and one of 62 Democrats who voted for the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act. This is huge.
In addition, Jim Cooper was one of 48 House Democrats who voted for the American Jobs Creation Act, which extended three components of the Bush tax cuts: easing the marriage penalty, creating a 10% tax bracket on the bottom end of the income scale, and doubling the per child tax credit to $1,000.
He voted against Gun Manufacturer Liability, which would have allowed negligence lawsuits against gun manufacturers, sellers, and trade associations when criminals use firearms illegally. Cooper also voted for Class Action Lawsuit Reform, a bill that moves many national class-action lawsuits out of local and state courts and into federal courts in order to stop “court shopping.”
Congressman Cooper voted for a “Death Tax” repeal, which makes permanent the now-temporary repeal of the death tax on family inheritances and businesses passed in 2001. He voted against using taxpayer funds to pay for overseas abortions, voted in support of saying the Pledge of Allegiance in schools, and voted against the Medicare prescription drug benefit.
All of these are conservative votes on high-profile legislation, and in almost all cases, Jim Cooper bucked the Democrat Party’s position. No, Jim Cooper is not a conservative, but that he willing to go against his party and vote conservative on legislation that is of paramount importance to conservatives earned Mr. Cooper a Right-Minded vote this year.
Conservatives agree that our philosophy succeeds whenever it’s applied, and it shouldn’t matter who applies it. Conservatism works for Democrats as well as conservatives. Honest conservatives aren’t afraid to lift substance over style, and adhere to ideology more than a political party. This means that sometimes it’s okay for a conservative to vote Democrat.




